Justice Souter retires; Arlen Specter rejoices; I weep
I have genuine love for Justice Souter (despite him being the only actual judicial conservative on the SCOTUS bench), and I have serious concerns about President Obama’s priorities in appointing his replacement. To wit, if Sonia Sotomayor is ensconced at One First Street, I will be monstrously displeased. She is a great appellate judge, but a Supreme Court Justice must be so much more than a keen legal mind. There needs to be a vision of the law, a commitment to balancing the rights of the individual in society, a higher consciousness. Also, of course, I doubt that Sotomayor could be successfully confirmed, but the buzz is getting a little out of hand.
Anyway, here is the bottom line: my pick is Diane Wood, for having everything Sotomayor lacks. I’m betting that President Obama’s pick will be Leah Ward Sears.